Anoushka Warlow, Partner and Associate, Amelia Clegg share their perspectives, six months on from the introduction of the “failure to prevent fraud” (FTPF) offence under the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023, as there have been no prosecutions or confirmed investigations. While this is not unexpected, given the offence is not retrospective and corporate investigations are complex, it leaves open key questions around who will bring the first case, in what circumstances, and how effective the new offence will be in practice.
Key Points
- No enforcement yet: Despite significant interest, there have been no charges or live investigations under the FTPF offence to date.
- Likely public prosecutors: The Serious Fraud Office (SFO) has expressed a clear ambition to lead the first prosecution, with the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) also well-positioned given its recent activity in corporate crime cases.
- Private prosecutions in play: Unlike similar offences under the Bribery Act 2010, FTPF does not require consent from the Director of Public Prosecutions, opening the door to private prosecutions by individuals, companies, shareholders or pressure groups.
- Growing trend: Private prosecutions have increased in recent years, often used where complainants are dissatisfied with the pace or priorities of public authorities.
- Strategic advantages: Potential benefits include reputational impact, collective shareholder action, and a more favourable cost framework compared to civil litigation.
- Significant risks: Private prosecutors face strict scrutiny from the courts, particularly around improper motives, evidential standards, and cost recovery.
- Financial exposure: Even successful prosecutions may not guarantee full recovery of costs, especially where courts consider the case should have been brought by public authorities.
To read the full article, click here.
Anoushka Warlow
Partner
Amelia Clegg
Senior Associate
More like this
Transparency does not stop crime – John Binns writes for The Times
BCL partner, John Binns writes for The Times discussing whether additional transparency and enforcement will be effective against economic crime in 2023.
BCL Solicitors LLP Celebrates Top Rankings in Chambers High Net Worth 2024 Guide
BCL Named Financial Crime & Investigations Team of the Year
We are thrilled to announce that BCL's Financial Crime & Investigations team has been awarded Team of the Year at the Chambers and Partners High Net Worth Awards!
BCL Solicitors LLP Celebrates Top Rankings in Chambers High Net Worth 2025 Guide
We are thrilled to announce that BCL Solicitors LLP has once again been recognised for excellence in the Chambers High Net Worth 2025 guide. Our firm has retained its esteemed Band 1 ranking in the Financial Crime: High Net Worth Individuals category, reaffirming our strong commitment to providing top-tier legal services to our clients.
BCL Recognised in Chambers & Partners 2026 Rankings
We are thrilled to announce that BCL Solicitors LLP has once again been recognised for excellence in the Chambers 2026 Guide.
SFO Offers No Evidence Against Rachel Rhodes After Decade-Long Investigation
After an investigation and prosecution lasting almost a decade, the Serious Fraud Office yesterday offered no evidence against BCL client Rachel Rhodes, former Chief Financial Officer of London Mining plc. Ms Rhodes has consistently maintained her innocence, and yesterday’s not guilty verdicts follow the SFO’s decision that there was no realistic prospect of conviction.
How to cope with an HMRC investigation – the five psychological stages
Nothing can prepare most people for the emotional turbulence that follows the receipt of a letter from HMRC, particularly if it is from the Fraud Investigation Service.
How Taxpayer Behaviour Shapes Schedule 24 Penalties
When HMRC discovers an inaccuracy in a tax return, it is rarely the case that the taxpayer will simply be asked to pay the difference.